In 2023 and 2024, two tragic instances in Florida and Belgium led to AI chatbot therapy coming under intense questioning, after psychiatric emergency men visited chatbots, highlighting the desire to know when such interventions would prove to be more hurtful than helpful.
This lead asks for greater examination of how much AI technology is being used across mental health, and if so, if it’s safe. People are warning that AI chatbot therapy, while helpful at the moment, lacks the protection and sensitivity of human intervention.
The change in examining those risks begins here.
How AI Therapy Fails in Crisis
Stanford researchers recently found that low-cost, widely available AI coach therapy devices can carry great risks like bias, misinterpretation, or even dangerous advice especially when handling suicidal or delusional thoughts. In trials, well-used therapy boots demonstrated stigma against disorders like schizophrenia and alcoholism and responded inappropriately to critical cues.
One tragic example, after a user reported they had lost their job, the bot offered a list of tall bridges in New York, rather than support or intervention.
The study also emphasized that newer or bigger models aren’t necessarily safer. Despite more training data, biases and crisis judgment flaws persisted across iterations. As lead author Jared Moore put it, “business as usual is not good enough”.
Why AI Won’t Replace Actual Therapy
One serious concern is excessive reliance on therapy alternative models which are emotionally soothing but lack clinical insight. Chatbots are programmed to reflect user input without rejecting dangerous thinking.
The AI therapist risk is particularly unsafe for vulnerable clients. They have the ability to reify delusions or suicidal thoughts merely because they validate false assumptions rather than deflect them.
These systems also create AI hallucinations, confident but false statements that lead consumers seeking mental health help astray. Without human-like emotional intelligence or accountability, chatbots have the potential to misdiagnose or fail to perceive urgency, putting users at higher risk
Stanford suggests a possible location for AI, not as a replacement, but as a tool to support clinicians. Chatbots can be used to do work like appointment reminders, note-taking summaries, or journaling suggestions under human oversight, not as full AI coach duplicates
The Bigger Picture
Other concerns are raised by experts about AI diagnosis because such systems are not transparent and tend to be black boxes. They can misread cultural or language variations, which can result in inappropriate judgments or unintended bias.
There is also concern about data privacy. In contrast to licensed therapists, chatbots can keep sensitive user chats that lack legal protection. Nevertheless, the advantages of chatbots like being 24/7 available and eliminating cost barriers are the winning card.
Stanford’s researchers do not call for an outright ban on AI. In contrast, they suggest balancing human control with AI assistance, guaranteeing safeguards against safety protocols, bias testing, and transparently communicating restrictions.
While AI chatbot therapy is increasingly used especially by those seeking quick or affordable help experts warn it’s no substitute for professional care. AI therapy risks from unmonitored use, hidden biases, and the illusion of comfort are not to be neglected.
AI may assist trained therapists, with journaling or administrative support, but empathy, judgment, and accountability remain fundamental to mental health treatment. Therefore, it is not advisable to seek help from AI and mental health chatbots while experiencing emotional suffering.
In the end, AI chatbot therapy offers scalable support but without the depth of clinical reasoning, it remains surface-level care. This gap reveals a deeper challenge: balancing widespread access with the need for real, human understanding.
Inside Telecom provides you with an extensive list of content covering all aspects of the tech industry. Keep an eye on our Intelligent Tech sections to stay informed and up-to-date with our daily articles.