WhatsApp Denies India Access to the Encrypted Text Messages

WhatsApp is threatening to pull its app from India if the government forces it to compromise encrypted text messages in compliance with Rule 4(2).

• In 2021, India introduced Rule 4(2), requiring social media companies to disclose message originators upon court order.
• WhatsApp argues that complying with the regulation would necessitate breaking its end-to-end encryption, leading to mass surveillance and compromising user privacy.

Meta’s WhatsApp is threatening to pull its app from India if the government forces it to compromise its end-to-end encryption.

In 2021, the Indian government introduced a new rule under the Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules. This rule, dubbed Rule 4(2), requires social media companies that provide messaging services to reveal the originator of a message if ordered to do so by a court or competent authority.

The offenses that would trigger the rule include national security, public order, or those related to rape, sexually explicit material, or child sexual abuse material. Rule 4(2) aims to combat issues such as fake news, hate speech, and other forms of harmful content on digital platforms. As far as the court is concerned, privacy rights are not absolute, and “somewhere balance has to be done.”

However, WhatsApp argued that complying with this regulation would require breaking its end-to-end encryption, thus compromising user privacy. It further argues that such measures would amount to mass surveillance and fundamentally alter its security model.

During the hearing, WhatsApp’s counsel, Tejas Karia, was firm in the company’s stance, stating, “As a platform, we are saying, if we are told to break encryption, then WhatsApp goes.” He went on to explain just exactly what the government’s request entails, “We will have to keep a complete chain and we don’t know which messages will be asked to be decrypted. It means millions and millions of messages will have to be stored for a number of years.” That’s a lot of data to be kept around on the off chance the court might need it.

Whether WhatsApp stays and complies or leaves India, the company will most probably be losing. If it decides to comply, it will jeopardize the encrypted text messages and, in turn, user privacy. Not only that but it will also set a precedent that will open the gates for other countries to demand the same. If that happens, WhatsApp’s users will lose their already shaky faith in the application’s security. If it leaves India, the messaging app will lose its largest user base, approximately 493.31 million users (as of 2021), impacting its global market share and potentially its revenue. Losing its users in India could also weaken its bargaining power with other businesses and the government.

Either way, WhatsApp is losing something, but will it prioritize its users’ privacy over numbers and profits?

Inside Telecom provides you with an extensive list of content covering all aspects of the tech industry. Keep an eye on our Tech sections to stay informed and up-to-date with our daily articles.