A European media executive’s declaration that EU tech sovereignty is “a dream that will never come true” has collided publicly with a coalition of European cloud providers, lawmakers, and civil society groups demanding that Europe must build, buy, and protect its own technology instead of deepening reliance on American platforms.
Europe is hoping for AI independence, in the executive’s eyes is not realistic, arguing that cooperation with the US offers a more realistic path, as European cloud providers seek political backing to reduce reliance on US technology and strengthen alternatives.
What Mathias Döpfner Said About EU’s Tech Sovereignty
Axel Springer Chief Executive, Mathias Döpfner, announced in a September interview – recorded shortly before he interviewed Palantir Chairman, Peter Thiel at the Axel Springer Award in Berlin – that European AI sovereignty is out of reach because the technological gap with the US and China is too large to close.
“A wonderful dream, and some dreams never come true,” Döpfner described EU’s sovereignty aspiration as “sovereignty illusion that Europe should abandon, arguing Europe should instead decide “with whom to join forces,” according to Dealroom.
Döpfner, whose company owns the news outlets Politico and Business Insider, ended his attack on the EU’s tech-nationalist pursuits by expressing that an open society, “that can only be the Americans.”
Back in July, in a separate remark, Döpfner flatly rejected the notion of a European digital sovereignty, “I absolutely don’t believe in the idea of European sovereignty when it comes to tech,” urging Europe to “embrace America. Embrace India. Embrace Japan,” and build AI “together” rather than independently.
His remarks, stated by Dealroom, put a question at the center of Europe’s digital debate: how much control can the continent build while relying on foreign technology?
For EU governments and businesses, the answer involves security, competition, and systems’ accessibility.
Döpfner’s stance shuts down the idea behind European cloud providers seeking a stronger domestic industry. However, AI independence and control over cloud services are different objectives, even when they overlap in public debate.
For European cloud service providers, the jest of the matter is not operating digital infrastructure, as it doesn’t necessarily mean developing every chip, model, or application that runs on it.
As cloud computing Europe landscape wrestles over the future of its data, policymakers will have to choose which technological choke points to dismantle first. For the EU, true self-reliance cannot be bought off the chain, but requires deeply rooted structural changes, not just a new roster of suppliers.
Assessing the biggest cloud providers in Europe also requires distinguishing companies serving European customers from businesses owned and controlled within Europe.
European Cloud Providers Oppose Döpfner
The EU tech-nationalist pursuits Döpfner dismissed is exactly what a group of 13 European cloud provider, EU lawmakers, and civil society organizations formally endorsed in a joint letter in June 2026, ahead of European Commission measures announced that same week, according to Reuters.
Signatories included French cloud provider OVHcloud, Germany’s Nextcloud and Swiss privacy company Proton, browser company Ecosia, and Dutch quantum chipmaker QuantWare, alongside lawmakers from the European Parliament’s Greens group including Defend Democracy and Save Social.
“Technological sovereignty means that Europe has the capacity to freely design, understand, choose-from different home-grown sources, build, operate, and effectively regulate the digital systems on which its society and economy rely on,” according to the letter from the biggest cloud providers in Europe, and the other representatives.
The open letter from the European based cloud providers described sovereignty as per how European digital engineers see and deem it to be.
“Our message is simple: Build European, buy European, protect European,” European Parliament lawmaker, Alexandra Geese, summarized the coalition’s position in one line.
For European cloud service providers, that approach could connect political ambitions with purchasing decisions. Reuters reported planned measures favoring European suppliers for sensitive public cloud tenders, alongside support for European chip production.
Still, European hosting alone cannot settle every question raised by digital sovereignty. Buyers must consider who operates a service, which rules apply and whether it meets their needs.
On September 4, that defense officials opposed restrictions on foreign technology in sensitive systems, warning of weaker capabilities, cyber risks and difficulties coordinating with NATO allies.
That resistance places European cloud providers between industrial ambitions and immediate operational demands. Defense procurement makes the tradeoff particularly sharp because changing systems must also preserve military effectiveness.
For cloud infrastructure providers in Europe, the practical challenge is demonstrating that greater domestic control can come with dependable performance.
The phrase European sovereign cloud providers in Europe points to that ambition, but a sovereignty label still needs clear conditions that buyers can assess.
Likewise, comparisons of the biggest cloud providers in Europe should consider suitability for a particular task, alongside size and ownership.
The debate over cloud computing Europe ultimately needs measurable goals. Governments should explain which dependencies matter, what alternatives can deliver, and how transitions would work.
European hosting demand may support local capacity, but purchasing rules need credible technical requirements.
That makes implementation central, political support can open opportunities, while users still need services that meet their daily requirements.
Döpfner’s skepticism and the providers’ campaign leave European cloud providers confronting the same test: whether Europe can gain meaningful control without sacrificing the capabilities its public services and security depend on.
Döpfner Position on Europe’s AI Governance
Instead of expecting lawmakers to play fortune-teller, Döpfner called for the flexible tech regulations that adapt on the fly, warning that intellectual property rules need an urgent upgrade to keep rewarding research and creative work. That will consequently apply to cloud modernization service providers in Europe.
According to Dealroom, Döpfner also said that technological progress “can never be slowed down,” pushing back on call for caution from AI executives, xAI’s Elon Musk, OpenAI’s Sam Altman, and Anthropic’s Dario Amodei, warning that if the West slows down its AI development while China accelerates, the West then, would be handing Beijing the advantage.
The media executive insisted on “iterative regulation” – rules developed through continuous observation and correction instead of legislation written in advance – because regulators “will always lag behind” the technology itself.
Palantir’s Thiel Intersection with Döpfner
Palantir’s Peter Thiel’s framing accepts the same starting fact as Döpfner’s. Thiel’s own framing – delivered in the same Berlin conversation – solidifies Döpfner’s argument from a commercial side.
Thiel evidenced Palantir’s accelerating US corporate sales as evidence that American urgency around AI adoption is outrunning European “fear of success,” arguing no large scalable Germany company has built since roughly 1995.
Thiel then went to compare Europe’s current trajectory to Minitel, France’s failed 1980’s digital precursor, rather than to Concorde, the program in which European aerospace engineering briefly matched and exceeded American capability.
In the Palantir chairman’s telling, it’s a historical marking of what Europe is failing to replicate this time.
Inside Telecom provides you with an extensive list of content covering all aspects of the tech industry. Keep an eye on our Intelligent Tech sections to stay informed and up-to-date with our daily articles.