What A Bigger Cyber Budget Should Buy

Cyber Budget

When cyber budgets rise and results stay the same, it’s worth asking what the money is buying. That is where UK cyber security finds itself. More than half of the UK technology executives surveyed by KPMG this year planned to increase their cyber security budgets by more than 10 per cent. Yet the government’s latest Cyber Security Breaches Survey found 43 per cent of businesses had identified a breach or attack in the previous 12 months, the same proportion as a year earlier.

My reading is that much of the investment is aimed at the wrong problem. Security spending has traditionally gone on protecting an organization’s own estate, and that is still where boards feel most comfortable putting money. Attackers have shifted their attention to the points where one organization’s responsibility ends and another’s begins, and to the routine maintenance that too often has no clear owner.

Where Responsibility Ends, Risk Begins

Suppliers are the clearest example. Verizon’s latest Data Breach Investigations Report found a third party was involved in 48 per cent of the breaches it analysed, a 60 per cent rise in a year. Only 15 per cent of UK businesses have formally reviewed the cyber risks posed by their immediate suppliers. Any supplier with a login to your systems is part of your security, whether you have assessed it or not. The attacks on M&S and Jaguar Land Rover showed how far the consequences can travel once a supply chain is involved.

Telecom operators live with this more than most. A network is built from equipment vendors, managed service providers, interconnect partners and legacy systems that may have been in place for decades. The Salt Typhoon campaign showed how state-backed attackers exploit supply chains and older systems to get in. An operator can secure its own core thoroughly and still be exposed through a partner it depends on every day. I would treat supplier assurance in this sector as an engineering discipline, owned by the people who run the network.

Patching is the other gap. In Verizon’s data, exploiting software vulnerabilities was the initial route for 31 per cent of breaches, overtaking stolen credentials. Patching rarely features in cyber budget discussions because it produces nothing new to point at. Yet the time it takes to fix a critical flaw on an internet-facing system is one of the most honest measures of how well protected an organisation really is.

AI raises the stakes on both. On 3 November, Richard Horne, chief executive of the National Cyber Security Centre, warned of a real prospect of an unprecedented rise in cyber incidents. He was clear that this is “not because AI has invented new ways to attack us”, and I share that view. AI helps attackers do familiar things faster and more convincingly, whether that’s scanning for unpatched systems or impersonating a colleague on the phone. The answer lies mostly in disciplines organisations should already have. Critical fixes need to go in quickly, and payment details should never be changed without a call back to a known number.

What a Bigger Cyber Budget Should Buy

So what should a bigger cyber budget buy? Less new technology than many boards might expect. I would put multi-factor authentication on every account and keep a complete record of which suppliers can reach which systems and data. I would also cut each supplier’s access back to what it genuinely needs and write breach-notification duties into contracts. Above all, I would make sure there is an incident response plan that has been rehearsed. Only a quarter of UK businesses have a formal plan, let alone one that has been tested. The organizations that recover best are those that have covered the basics, know their suppliers and have rehearsed their response.

Boards also need evidence that the money is working. I would ask for three numbers: how long it takes to apply a critical patch, how quickly a supplier’s access can be revoked, and how long it takes to restore an essential service in a rehearsal. A business that can answer those with confidence is far better protected than one that can only point to the size of its budget.


Inside Telecom provides you with an extensive list of content covering all aspects of the tech industry. Keep an eye on our Insights sections to stay informed and up-to-date with our daily articles.

Join our WhatsApp Channel WhatsApp Channel